Miscarriage platitudes

Following on from my earlier post ‘Words can be tricky, in panels’, I did a new comic page about one of the phrases used when people seek words to make a miscarriage-sufferer feel better. I understand that it’s hard to find the right thing to say at times. Below is my response to “It wasn’t meant to be”.

I’m not religious and I tend not to believe in fate or karma; this phrase suggests that such ideas are somehow involved, the presumption being that this will make the situation easier to accept. Fine if it does help some people, of course. The way I see it, for better or worse, nature just does its stuff and may cause sadness, joy or neither. I should probably have put all that in the comic, but I hope to go into it in more detail in my graphic memoir.

Do click twice to view larger if it’s a bit fuzzy!  I’ve also made a little stamp of my initials, carved out of a rubber, with which to sign future work.

4 thoughts on “Miscarriage platitudes

  1. My instant reaction is 😦 . As with most powerfully sad things, less is definitely more. But I think I’d be inclined to big up the crosses, especially with the contraception panel. Why not have a cross across the whole lot? At the moment it looks a bit like a teacher has marked your biology book cos you’ve not identified the right contraceptive device. (I don’t mean that in a mean way – if only my biology book had been as beautifully drawn as this!)

    • Thanks Lucy – originally I was going to put a cross through whole thing – not sure why I didn’t but I might do now you mention it – shall try it out at least.

  2. I love it – and a graphic memoir sounds amazing. (Saw you comment on Lisa’s LWB blog and got curious.)

    I also hate hate HATE the “it wasn’t meant to be” statements, because if you use that logic for a miscarriage (or anything), then you need to apply that to everything else too. So the crack addict who has child addicted to crack – THAT was “meant to be?” Or a much loved child in my life was MEANT to have cystic fibrosis? Or a friend of my husband’s is MEANT to die as a result of skin cancer? I mean, it is so ignorant, and insulting.

    • Thanks for looking! I know what you mean. It’s quite a facile statement but one that I think people use when they feel they ought to have an answer, explanation or some words rather than none. It’s too nebulous for me. It probably comes from a good place but unfortunately stokes the ire of many a recipient!

      I love the title ‘No Kidding’! I wanted to call my book that a while back, but soon discovered that it was already being used. It’s great.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s